Contents
The marketing KPIs that really matter for an SME are customer value, cost per customer won, cost per qualified enquiry, close rate and revenue per channel. Impressions, clicks, followers and rankings, on the other hand, are often vanity metrics: they look good in a report and still say nothing about whether your marketing makes money. Hierarchy uses these five numbers to calculate upfront whether SEO, GEO or advertising pay off for you, then builds the funnel that turns visitors into enquiries and enquiries into customers.
Many management teams know the monthly report: impressions are up 40 percent, twelve new keywords are on page one, traffic is growing. Every curve points up. Then comes the question the report doesn't answer: how many new customers did this bring us, and was it worth it?
That question is where our work starts. This article shows which marketing KPIs really matter, how to calculate and measure them and how we check upfront whether a channel pays off for you.
Which marketing KPIs really matter
For most SMEs, five numbers are enough to manage marketing like an investment. Our example is an accounting firm that wins new SME clients through SEO and GEO for an assumed CHF 2,000 a month. In a year in which the channel is up and running, it brings 24 qualified enquiries and 6 new clients.
| KPI | Formula | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Customer value (customer lifetime value) | Contribution margin per year × length of the client relationship | CHF 4,000 × 5 years = CHF 20,000 |
| Cost per customer (CAC) | Channel cost ÷ customers won | CHF 24,000 ÷ 6 = CHF 4,000 |
| Cost per qualified enquiry | Channel cost ÷ qualified enquiries | CHF 24,000 ÷ 24 = CHF 1,000 |
| Close rate | Orders ÷ qualified enquiries | 6 ÷ 24 = 25 % |
| Revenue per channel | Revenue of all orders whose enquiry came from the channel | evaluated by source in the CRM |
Three notes on this:
- Contribution margin, not revenue: for customer value, what counts is what is left after direct costs. Only that amount is available for acquisition.
- Qualified means a fit: a qualified enquiry fits your offer, your region and your price range. Spam, job applications and enquiries for services you don't offer don't count.
- The most important ratio is customer value to CAC. In the example it is CHF 20,000 to CHF 4,000, so 5 to 1. Many companies set the limit at 3 to 1 or better. Below that, acquisition eats too much of the profit.
If you want to be precise, include sales effort in CAC as well, meaning the time spent on first meetings and quotes.
Three levels: goal, steering, early indicator
Rankings and traffic are not worthless. They just belong on a different level. We assign every metric to one of three levels:
| Level | Metrics | Question behind it | How often to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goal | Revenue per channel, cost per customer, customer value | Does the channel pay off? | quarterly |
| Steering | Qualified enquiries, cost per enquiry, close rate, enquiry rate of landing pages | Where in the funnel are customers lost? | monthly |
| Early indicator | Rankings for terms with buying intent, clicks from search, mentions in AI answers | Is the work heading in the right direction? | weekly to monthly |
With SEO and GEO it takes a few months until the goal level becomes meaningful. In that time, the early indicators show whether the work is having an effect. How we measure mentions in ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews is covered in Measuring AI visibility.
A vanity metric is what you get when an early indicator is reported as the goal.
What vanity metrics are and why they are so popular
A vanity metric is a number that rises without anything changing in the business. It is popular because it is easy to measure, almost always grows and presents well. More content brings more impressions, more ad budget brings more clicks. Whether the right people arrive and buy from you is another matter.
| Vanity metric | What it shows | What it doesn't show | The better question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Impressions | How often you were shown | Whether anyone was interested | How many qualified enquiries came from this channel? |
| Clicks and traffic | How many visitors came | Whether they were potential customers | How many visitors became enquiries? |
| Number of rankings | How many terms you are found for | Whether customers search for those terms | Does the page that sells your most profitable service rank? |
| Click-through rate and CPC | How cheap a click was | How expensive a customer was | What does a customer won cost per channel? |
| Number of leads | How many forms came in | How many of them wanted to buy | How many leads became quotes and orders? |
| Followers and likes | How big the reach is | Whether the reach buys | Which revenue can be traced back to the channel? |
It gets difficult when numbers like these are the only ones in the report. Then a team optimises for what is in the report. Your business, however, needs orders.
Calculate upfront: do SEO or GEO pay off for you?
Before we talk about channels, we answer three questions with you: What is a customer worth to you? Up to what acquisition cost do you still make a good profit? And how many enquiries does a channel have to bring to pay off? If you don't have these numbers yet, we work them out together from invoices, CRM data and a conversation with your sales team. That is the situation at most SMEs, and a good estimate is enough to start.
For the accounting firm from the example, the calculation before the start looks like this:
| Step | Value |
|---|---|
| Customer value of a client | CHF 20,000 |
| Affordable acquisition cost (a quarter of customer value) | CHF 5,000 |
| Close rate from qualified enquiry to client | 25 % |
| Affordable cost per qualified enquiry (CHF 5,000 × 25 %) | CHF 1,250 |
| Monthly cost of SEO and GEO | CHF 2,000 |
| Qualified enquiries needed per month (CHF 2,000 ÷ CHF 1,250) | about 1.6 |
From about 1.6 qualified enquiries a month, the channel pays off. If it brings two, a 25 % close rate means six new clients a year. A client then costs about CHF 4,000, well below the limit of CHF 5,000. Over the full length of the relationships, the six clients bring CHF 120,000 in contribution margin, at a cost of CHF 24,000 a year. Because SEO and GEO need a few months to ramp up and content keeps working afterwards, we look at such calculations over 12 to 24 months.
The reverse case matters just as much. If you sell a one-off product with a CHF 80 margin, a CHF 2,000 monthly content programme only pays off with very high demand. Then we tell you before the start and recommend the channel that does pay off. More on the method is on the sales funnel and customer acquisition page.
Clicks are the start: funnels that turn visitors into customers
More visitors are often not the fastest way to more customers. A simple example with 1,000 visitors a month:
| Stage | Today | After funnel optimisation |
|---|---|---|
| Visitors | 1,000 | 1,000 |
| Share who enquire | 2 % | 3 % |
| Qualified enquiries | 20 | 30 |
| Close rate | 25 % | 35 % |
| New customers | 5 | 10.5 |
The same traffic produces twice as many customers, without a single franc of extra ad budget. The levers for this sit after the click:
- Landing pages that answer one question and lead to exactly one next step: enquiry, call-back, appointment.
- Lead magnets for visitors who aren't ready to enquire yet, such as a calculator or a checklist. In our case study with a solar provider, 12 % of the solar calculator's visitors became leads.
- Fast response: enquiries land in the CRM instead of an inbox, are scored, assigned and confirmed immediately.
- Following up after the quote: many orders are lost because nobody calls back after the quote.
- Tracking through to the order: every enquiry keeps its source, so you see per channel what a customer costs.
How to measure marketing KPIs in practice
The five numbers come from three sources that have to work together:
- Website tracking: Google Analytics 4 and Google Tag Manager record forms, clicks on the phone number and email address and appointment bookings as conversions. Visits from ChatGPT and other AI assistants usually appear in GA4 as referrals, for example from chatgpt.com. On every website we build, we set up GA4, Search Console and Tag Manager.
- A CRM with the source: every enquiry is created with its source, meaning channel, campaign and landing page, and moves through the same stages until it becomes an order or is lost. Only then can close rate, cost per customer and revenue per channel be calculated.
- The question in the conversation: "How did you hear about us?" belongs in the form and in every first meeting. Recommendations from AI answers often leave no trace in tracking, because customers then type the name straight into Google.
For Google Ads, we feed closed orders from the CRM back as offline conversions. The bidding strategy then optimises for customers, not just for clicks or forms. More on this on the Google Ads agency page.
Strategy with a business owner's eye
Before we plan a channel, we look at the business and ask questions many marketing plans leave out:
- Which service is the most profitable? The page for your highest-margin offer gets content, links and ad budget first, even if another service has more search volume.
- Do you have capacity for more customers? A funnel that brings more enquiries than your team can handle costs money and reputation. We plan growth along your capacity.
- Which customers do you want more of? We aim content and ads at the customers who pay well and stay long.
- How is search changing? More and more customers ask ChatGPT, Gemini or Google's AI Mode for a provider. We are building today the visibility that will decide enquiries in two years.
Every month we check in the strategy review whether the numbers are on track and move budget and work to where they bring the most. Strategy and implementation sit in the same team. What we decide, we implement ourselves: content, pages, technical changes and tracking. Your webmaster doesn't have to do anything.
Marketing and sales at one table
Marketing reports more leads, sales says they are poor. This argument exists in many companies, and it costs orders.
In our experience, that is why collaboration between marketing and sales is mandatory. Only sales knows whether an enquiry was good. Their feedback is what shows what to do next in the funnel:
| What sales reports | What it means | What we do |
|---|---|---|
| Many enquiries, but poor quality | The funnel attracts the wrong prospects | Fix the funnel: align keywords and ads with buying intent, state target group, region and price range clearly on the landing page, add qualifying questions to the form and score leads |
| Good enquiries and a good close rate | The funnel is working | Scale as long as cost per customer stays below the limit: more content for SEO and GEO, more budget for Google Ads, further services or regions |
| Good enquiries, but few deals closed | Customers are lost after the enquiry | Improve response time, first meeting, quote and follow-up, with a clear sales process and automated workflows in the CRM |
| Good quality, but too few enquiries | Visibility isn't enough yet | Find the biggest gaps with an SEO audit, expand visibility on Google and in AI answers and bridge the gap with ads until the organic channels carry the load |
That's why marketing and sales discuss lead quality together in the monthly strategy review, with the same stages, the same definition of a qualified enquiry and the same numbers.
For this, Hierarchy has a dedicated sales expert on the team: Stefan Martins da Silva brings over 15 years of sales experience, including roles at Microsoft and SwissSign. He builds the sales pipeline with you, defines qualification criteria and the quoting process and advises your sales team directly. If processes or a CRM are missing, we implement them. If they are already running, we make them better, up to automating everything from quote to invoice.
The benefit runs both ways. What sales learns about customers flows back into marketing: which search terms bring the customers who actually buy, which objections come up in every conversation and which questions a page should answer upfront.
Fast and with no minimum term
Anyone who wants to be measured by profit has to accept being measured by it. That's why we work without a minimum term, you can cancel at any time, and accounts, data and content belong to you. We have to convince you again every month, with your own numbers.
Then there is speed. We work with our own data pipelines and AI-assisted workflows, steer content week by week from search, ranking and AI data and deliver analyses and implementation fast, at the current state of the art in SEO and GEO. If your website is outdated, we can rebuild it in a modern framework on request, optimised for search and AI, with a redirect plan so no rankings are lost.
Checklist: does your report show business results?
Whether you work with us or not, these six questions help with any marketing report.
- Does the report show revenue, or at least the number of orders, per channel?
- Is it clear what a qualified enquiry is, and is it counted separately from all forms?
- Is there a target for cost per customer, derived from your customer value?
- Are rankings and traffic shown as early indicators or sold as success?
- Is there a monthly decision on what gets cut or expanded?
- Can you verify the numbers yourself in your own accounts?
If you can answer yes to all six, you are managing marketing like an investment.
Conclusion
Reach is easy to buy and easy to report. For your business, what counts is what a channel brings in customers and contribution margin. Hierarchy calculates with you upfront whether a channel pays off, builds visibility on Google and in AI assistants, builds the funnel behind it and measures every channel through to the order. With no minimum term and no work for your webmaster.
In a first conversation we run a rough calculation of your customer value and affordable acquisition cost and show where your funnel is losing customers today.
